Everton Defeats Newcastle United 3-1 in EFL Cup Showdown
Everton hosted Newcastle United at the Hill Dickinson Stadium earlier tonight, aiming to secure a home victory in the EFL Cup. The Toffees began the match positively and took the lead in the 34th minute when James Garner scored. Hayden Hackney extended their advantage in the 45th minute, sending David Moyes’ squad into halftime with a 2-0 lead.
Thierno Barry sealed the match in the 69th minute with a goal, although Dan Burn managed to net one for the Magpies in the 88th minute. Ultimately, Everton emerged victorious, concluding the match with a solid 3-1 win in front of their home crowd.
Advertisement
Here’s a review of how each Everton player performed during the encounter against Newcastle.
The goalkeeper made several key saves, successfully limiting the opposition to just one goal.
RB: Merlin Rohl – 7/10
Rohl executed his defensive responsibilities competently but contributed little in attacking play.
CB: James Tarkowski – 7/10
Tarkowski displayed solid defending and was effective when in possession.
CB: Jake O’Brien – 6.5/10
O’Brien played his part in defense, ensuring the opposition wasn’t able to score more than once.
LIVERPOOL, ENGLAND – OCTOBER 29: Jacob Murphy of Newcastle United is challenged by Hayden Hackney of Everton during the Carabao Cup Fourth Round match between Everton and Newcastle United at Hill Dickinson Stadium on October 29, 2026 in Liverpool, England. (Photo by Jan Kruger/Getty Images)
Advertisement
LB: Vitaliy Mykolenko – 7.5/10
Mykolenko made a positive impact at both ends of the pitch.
CM: Hayden Hackney – 8/10
Hackney was dynamic, contributing both offensively and defensively, finishing the match with a goal and an assist.
CM: James Garner – 7.5/10
Garner worked tirelessly in midfield, finding the back of the net in the 34th minute.
RW: Tyler Dibling – 7/10
Dibling had moments of brilliance but was unable to score.
CAM: Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall – 7.5/10
Dewsbury-Hall was consistently troublesome for the opposition and achieved one assist.
LW: Tyrique George – 6.5/10
George created some challenges for his defender but did not look likely to score.
Advertisement
ST: Thierno Barry – 9/10
Barry was a pivotal figure for Everton, scoring one goal and assisting another during the match.
CM: Harrison Armstrong – 6/10
Armstrong brought energy to the midfield.
RW: Brennan Johnson – 6/10
Johnson’s influence on the game was limited.
CAM: Charly Alcaraz – 6/10
Alcaraz could not significantly impact the game.
